Sunday, November 22, 2026.
How Do You Get Over a Situationship That Never Officially Began?
“We weren’t together,” she tells her friend.
Her friend puts down her fork. “Then why did you make me take you to the airport to pick him up?”
There is apparently a difference between being someone’s girlfriend and standing at Terminal B holding his winter coat.
The coat, for one thing, was real enough to require a trip back across town when he wanted it.
For six months he’d called on his way home from work.
She knew which of his brothers he hoped would skip Thanksgiving. He knew how to get into her building when the buzzer stuck.
And now she has to explain why she’s crying about a man she spent six months insisting was casual.
Her friend asks when they broke up.
This is where things get awkward. There’s a date for the airport. There’s a date for the coat. The breakup is harder to locate.
There was a Sunday when he stopped calling, then a Thursday when he sent her a photograph of a dog that looked like a man they both knew.
What did we agree to?
A situationship is a romantic or sexual connection whose terms remain unclear.
Some folks choose that arrangement and enjoy it.
You can spend a lovely winter with someone and part in April with considerable affection and a mutually satisfactory division of the books. A short relationship can be conducted with more care than a long marriage.
The trouble starts when the arrangement begins asking more of you than either person has agreed to give.
One person thinks Saturday night is theirs unless somebody says otherwise. The other still thinks they’re making plans from scratch every Friday.
Both can sincerely say, “I thought we understood each other.” Ask them what they understood and you’ll hear two competent witnesses describe different accidents. That gap can widen when mutual curiosity reads implicit expectations differently.
There’s a reason to let some of this unfold. You may need time to know what you want.
When you do know, however, keeping quiet can become a way of keeping the relationship you have.
The sentence I want to know if we’re building something together might cost you Saturday night.
You can see why a person would postpone it until Sunday, and then until spring.
Dating apps changed the marketplace for romance.
The same phone lets an old connection stay just present enough to disturb a new afternoon. A soul can stop making plans with you and still send you exactly the photograph that makes you forget, for a minute, that they stopped making those sorts of plans.
The relationship ends. The question stays open.
Across three studies, Erica Slotter, Wendi Gardner, and Eli Finkel found that romantic breakups could change how folks described themselves and leave them less sure of who they were.
That loss of clarity was associated with emotional distress.
The researchers studied romantic breakups broadly.
Their work gives us a question worth asking about unnamed relationships too. How much of your life had already taken shape around this person?
You became someone who left work a little earlier on Thursdays.
Someone who knew which coffee to buy twice.
Someone who had begun to imagine being less careful with what she said. In the first weeks afterward, you may still find yourself making room for that person before you remember they won’t be coming.
Family therapist Pauline Boss’s work on ambiguous loss offers a way to think about what uncertainty adds to grief.
Her classic examples include families living with a disappearance or dementia.
An undefined romance is a different kind of loss, but her work raises a useful question here. How do you grieve when the facts that would make the loss intelligible are still in dispute?
Your friends may ask you to settle those facts before they know how to help.
Were you exclusive?
Did he ever introduce you as his partner?
You answer, and hear yourself making the case against your own grief.
Perhaps you go home and reread six months of messages looking for a sentence a jury would accept.
Some of what you miss happened.
Some of what you miss was going to happen, as far as you knew.
You can grieve dinner on Thursdays and the trip you’d already started pricing. It helps to know which is which, especially if you’re tempted to treat a future you privately imagined as a promise somebody broke.
What no contact can do
A five-year analysis of U.S. Google Trends found that relative search interest in no contact rule rose while interest in how to get over a breakup fell.
Search data tells us what people looked up. It can’t tell us what got them through a Thursday night.
Taking time away from contact may give you a chance to see how much of your week had become a vigil for the next message.
If you’re counting the days until the other person notices your absence, you’re still organizing your week around their response.
That’s an understandable first impulse.
It helps to admit it before you assign the silence an elaborate strategy.
If you have to see each other at work, distance may look like discussing the only thing you now have in common, which is work.
If the other person has been clear that they want to stop, you already have the answer that matters for your next decision.
And if the door is still open and it makes sense to speak, an ending can be plain.
I’ve cared about what we’ve had. I want a relationship we can both name and make plans for. I’m going to stop seeing you because we want different things.
You can say that even if the other person thinks the whole thing was casual. You’re telling them what you’ve decided. They can disagree with your account of the last six months and still understand what will happen next Thursday.
Tell your friend what happened
A friend can do more with “We spoke every night, and now we don’t” than with a twenty-minute explanation of why you’re technically fine.
If you can, ask for company at the hour you’ll actually miss them.
Dinner on Thursday. A walk after work. Somebody to sit in the kitchen while you put away the extra mug.
When you’re getting through a breakup, begin with the simplest account of what you lost, in words a friend can act on.
“We weren’t together,” she says.
Then, after a minute, she tries again.
“He called me every night on his way home. Six fifteen. It’s been three weeks and I still stop whatever I’m doing around six.”
Her friend picks up her fork. “Come over Thursday. Around six.
Be Well, Stay Kind, and Godspeed.
REFERENCES:
Boss, P. (1999). Ambiguous loss: Learning to live with unresolved grief. Harvard University Press. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctvjhzrh4
Slotter, E. B., Gardner, W. L., & Finkel, E. J. (2010). Who am I without you? The influence of romantic breakup on the self-concept. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36(2), 147–160. https://doi.org/10.1177/0146167209352250
If you and your partner keep circling the question of what you want from each other, you can explore my couples therapy services or contact me for a free introductory call.