Dating apps give us a common language for what we want. We get considerably more specific about what we can’t live with.
The man on the dating app describes himself as kind, loyal, and emotionally available. He is also, judging by the photograph, on a mountain.
Her friend asks what she thinks.
“He says he doesn’t do drama.”
“Oh,” her friend says.
The mountain, which took most of a Saturday to climb, has contributed almost nothing to the conversation.
“I don’t do drama” could mean he has excellent boundaries and a reasonably quiet life.
It could also mean that the last woman who asked him to call when he said he would is now, in his account, a difficult person.
The phrase leaves enough room for either man. Her friend has already met one of them.
What we want sounds remarkably alike
In seven experiments involving 1,074 people, psychologists Tabea J. Zorn and Christian Unkelbach found that folks could name more qualities they wanted in a potential partner than qualities they hoped to avoid.
Pool the answers from the two English-language listing experiments, though, and the numbers go the other way.
There were 181 distinct negative descriptors and 152 positive ones. The desirable traits also clustered more closely in emotional meaning. People had plenty to say in favor of a good partner, and much of it sounded alike. onlinelibrary.wiley.com
Trustworthy ranked first among the desirable traits.
Kind, loyal, genuine, and understanding followed. Abuse was the strongest dealbreaker, with infidelity and several varieties of dishonesty close behind.
Elsewhere on the list, a word could go either way. Some people wanted a partner who was flirtatious. Others put it on the list of things they’d had quite enough of. onlinelibrary.wiley.com
In one experiment, participants swiped right about 95% of the time when a hypothetical partner was described by a single positive trait.
They did so about 15% of the time, on average, when the word described a flaw, and their responses varied considerably depending on the word. In both swipe experiments, how closely a flaw resembled other negative traits helped predict rejection even after the researchers accounted for how important people said the flaw was. That added effect was smaller than the effect of the trait’s stated importance. These were judgments about one word at a time. Nobody saw a face or had to get through dinner. onlinelibrary.wiley.com
It was my sister’s wedding
Ask someone what they want in a partner and they’ll give you an adjective. Ask what they can’t go through again and they’ll tell you exactly where they were standing.
“It was my sister’s wedding,” she says.
Suddenly reliable has a time and a place. It means someone who will be downstairs at four, with the car, on a day when you have already spoken to the florist twice and your mother is standing in a hotel corridor holding a bag of ice.
Even kindness takes some explaining.
One person thinks kindness means asking what’s wrong as soon as the other goes quiet. The other thinks kindness means letting a person finish a sandwich in peace. Six months in, one is complaining about emotional distance and the other is eating lunch in the car.
Both can put kind on a dating profile with a clear conscience. They might even swipe right on each other.
That’s one consequence of moving courtship into a marketplace of profiles.
You meet the description before you meet the person. The description says easygoing. He might be easygoing because he can tolerate disappointment. He might be easygoing because his last partner spent eleven years making sure he never had to.
What people learn to leave out
Imagine a woman who spends most Sundays having lunch with her father. He’s eighty-six. It’s a standing arrangement. She considers putting it in her profile, then pictures a stranger reading it as an announcement that Sundays are spoken for. She writes family-oriented. This is true. It’s also what the man three profiles down wrote because he likes Thanksgiving.
The detail she took out would have told you something about what it’s like to be close to her.
She keeps promises. She may expect you to work around certain ones.
If you spend your Sundays with your own father, you might recognize something you’d like. You might also wonder when the two of you would ever get lunch.
Now imagine enough people making that same small editorial decision.
Each profile gets a little easier to approve of and a little harder to choose. So you look more closely for the line that gives something away. The person writing the next profile has every reason to take that line out, too.
I’ve written before about what happens when we optimize how we choose a partner. Here the peculiar result is that you can make yourself more broadly appealing by removing precisely the detail that would let somebody recognize you.
Of course, some details are worth taking seriously.
A person who treats a former partner’s fear as a funny story has told you something.
So has a person who makes a point of mentioning that they eat dinner at five. One detail might help you stay safe. The other might help you discover that you’ve been waiting your whole adult life to eat dinner at five without having to defend it.
There’s a certain comedy in spending all that time trying to sound like someone anybody could love.
The person who might actually love you has a schedule, a history, and a number of oddly specific wishes. They could use a little more to go on.
Maybe keep the mountain. Put the lunch with your father back in. Somebody reading might be glad to know what you do on Sundays. Somebody else will want to know where you take him.
Reference
Zorn, T. J., & Unkelbach, C. (2026). Valence asymmetries of traits in dating contexts. European Journal of Social Psychology. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.70121