The Right to Be Left Alone

Thursday, November 19, 2026.

Christopher Lasch and the defensive triumph of the private self

He comes home from the appointment and puts the envelope on the kitchen counter. His partner asks how it went.

“Fine,” he says.

She believes him. This is the first thing he holds against her.

Of course, he’d have resented a follow-up question. He’d spent the drive home rehearsing how to get through dinner without discussing the appointment.

What he wanted was for her to leave him alone in a very particular way, one that would make him feel less alone. He had no idea how to ask for this.

He was fairly sure that asking would ruin it.

She moves the envelope so she can set down the cutting board.

The freedom we won

The right to be left alone is a considerable achievement.

A woman can decline Sunday dinner at her parents’ house without submitting a medical certificate.

A man can stop taking calls from a brother who’s cruel when he drinks.

Two partners can get married and decide that neither set of parents needs a key. Some families have taken this last development harder than the marriage.

There was plenty to escape.

A great deal of what used to pass for community was compulsory attendance with refreshments. The people most likely to romanticize its obligations are often the ones who had somebody else in the kitchen.

The man with the envelope has every right to keep its contents to himself.

He also wants his partner to understand that it took something out of him to carry it home. He could tell her that much. It would feel, to him, like telling her everything.

The self under siege

In The Minimal Self, published in 1984, Christopher Lasch returned to a question he had left open in The Culture of Narcissism.

Why had so much attention to the self come to take the form of bare psychic survival?

Under siege, he wrote, “the self contracts to a defensive core, armed against adversity.” A future you have little confidence in is a difficult place to put a promise (books.google.com).

Lasch thought the trouble ran deeper than a dismal news cycle.

He argued that corporations, bureaucracies, and professional experts had taken over work that households and communities once knew how to do.

As we lost some of that everyday competence, we grew more dependent on institutions over which we ultimately have little influence.

The result was a peculiar kind of independence.

You could be freer of the people who knew you, and more reliant on organizations that barely knew you existed. (is.muni.cz).

His reading of Narcissus was stranger still.

Narcissus looks into the water and fails to recognize a reflection.

For Lasch, the story turns on a confusion about where the self ends and the world begins.

In his later account, the fantasy of perfect self-sufficiency promised relief from one of the hardest facts of life.

We need souls who have minds, wishes, and wills of their own.

A person can love you and still believe you when you say you’re fine (thezeitgeistmovement.se).

Related reading

Everything he can tell his phone

Suppose that, while she’s looking for the onion, he takes his phone into the bathroom.

He tells a chatbot exactly what the doctor said. He gives it the sentence he’s been replaying on the drive home.

He asks why he can remember every word of that sentence and almost nothing that came after it.

By the time he comes back to the kitchen, he has a decent account of what happened and a better idea of why it frightened him.

There’s real value in that.

Sometimes it’s easier to find the words when nobody is watching your face.

He could walk back into the kitchen and use some of those words.

He could also just put the phone back in his pocket, feel a little better, and then ask what they’re having for dinner.

What makes this distinctly modern is how much he can disclose while asking so little of anyone.

He can tell the whole story without having to ask somebody to put down a knife.

The machine in his pocket can help him describe the fear.

Asking his partner to sit with him would mean letting her see him before he’s worked out what to do with it.

There’s always the possibility that he’ll say the wrong thing.

There’s also the possibility that she’ll say, “Of course,” and he’ll realize how long he’s been waiting to hear it.

Lasch’s argument about dependence helps explain why an evening like this can feel so self-directed.

We can arrange dinner, distraction, and a sympathetic conversation without asking anyone we know to change their plans.

The freedom is real.

So is the practice we’re getting at keeping our more difficult days entirely to ourselves.

What happens when two private selves fall in love?

Some folks learned to say “I’m fine” because every disclosure became a cross-examination.

Some learned to believe “I’m fine” because asking twice used to start a fight.

Put them in a kitchen and their manners may be impeccable. Each is performing the other the courtesy they once wished their partner would do them.

In couples therapy, differentiation describes the capacity to remain a person in your own right while staying in relationship.

In practice it can look like saying, “I want you here, and I want to keep this part to myself.”

It can also look like hearing that sentence and pulling out a chair.

I’ve written about a version of this problem for couples who live apart.

Two life partners can be delighted to have their own homes and share Sunday coffee for years.

Then one comes home from the hospital and needs help getting dressed. Somebody has to say, “Come over before you make coffee.”

That is a small sentence with a surprising amount of pride riding on it.

The man with the envelope would like love to spare him that embarrassment.

Surely somebody who knows him this well will notice.

Sometimes she does. Sometimes she remembers a Tuesday six months ago when he said, quite sincerely, “Please stop asking me if I’m okay.”

By now she’s halfway through the onion.

He opens the refrigerator, studies its contents with the attention of a man considering a second opinion, and shuts it again.

“Would you sit with me for a minute?”

She puts down the knife. “Do you want to talk about it?”

“Maybe after dinner.”

She sits. The envelope stays where it is.

Be Well, Stay Kind, and Godspeed.

REFERENCES:

Lasch, C. (1979). The culture of narcissism: American life in an age of diminishing expectations. W. W. Norton.

Lasch, C. (1984). The minimal self: Psychic survival in troubled times. W. W. Norton. Book preview

Lasch, C. (1991). Afterword: The culture of narcissism revisited. In The culture of narcissism: American life in an age of diminishing expectations. W. W. Norton.

If you and your partner have gotten good at giving each other space and could use some help finding your way back into conversation, explore my couples therapy services or get in touch for a free introductory call.

Previous
Previous

The American Dream Has a Wanted Level

Next
Next

Grand Theft Auto Has Decided to Be Exclusive