My Husband Puts His Family Before Me: Understanding the Dynamics and Therapeutic Approaches
Wednesday, August 14, 2024.
When a spouse feels that their partner prioritizes their family of origin over their marital relationship, it can create significant tension, resentment, and feelings of inadequacy.
The phrase "my husband puts his family before me" reflects a common issue in marriages where boundaries between the marital relationship and the family of origin are unclear or poorly maintained.
This dynamic can lead to conflict, decreased marital satisfaction, and, in some cases, estrangement between partners.
Understanding the Dynamics
Enmeshment and Boundaries: In some families, boundaries between members are not well-defined, leading to enmeshment, where the individual's identity is intertwined with their family of origin.
A husband who prioritizes his family may have grown up in an enmeshed environment where family loyalty and dependence are valued over individuality and autonomy. This can make it difficult for him to establish appropriate boundaries between his family of origin and his marriage.
Cultural Expectations: Cultural factors can also play a significant role in this dynamic. In some cultures, there is a strong expectation that individuals, particularly men, remain deeply connected and loyal to their parents and siblings even after marriage. This cultural expectation can create a conflict of interest between fulfilling family obligations and investing in the marital relationship.
Guilt and Obligation: A husband may feel an overwhelming sense of guilt or obligation to his family, especially if they are in need of support. This sense of duty can override his commitment to his spouse, leading to situations where he prioritizes his family's needs over those of his partner. This can create feelings of neglect and resentment in the spouse, who may feel that their emotional needs are being overlooked.
Emotional Cutoff and Fusion: According to Bowen's Family Systems Theory, some folks may struggle with emotional cutoff or fusion with their family of origin.
Emotional cutoff occurs when a person distances themselves from their family to avoid unresolved emotional issues, while fusion refers to the blurring of boundaries and over-involvement with family members.
Both dynamics can contribute to a situation where a husband either cannot detach from his family's influence or feels compelled to maintain a close connection at the expense of his marriage.
Cultural Issues in "My Husband Puts His Family Before Me"
Cultural factors play a significant role in shaping individuals' beliefs, values, and behaviors, particularly when it comes to family dynamics and marital relationships. In many cultures, the family of origin holds a central place, and loyalty to parents and siblings is highly valued.
When a husband places his family of origin above his marriage, cultural expectations often influence this behavior, creating complex challenges for both partners.
Collectivist vs. Individualist Cultures
In collectivist cultures, the needs of the group (in this case, the family of origin) are often prioritized over the needs of the individual.
Collectivist societies, such as those found in many Asian, African, and Latin American countries, emphasize interdependence, loyalty, and duty to one's family. In these contexts, it is not uncommon for a husband to feel obligated to put his family's needs above his own, including those of his spouse.
Expectation of Filial Piety: In many collectivist cultures, filial piety—a deep respect for and obligation to one's parents—is a core value.
This expectation can create a situation where a husband feels torn between his loyalty to his parents and his commitment to his wife. The pressure to fulfill familial obligations can lead to a husband prioritizing his family's needs over his marriage, even if it causes tension with his spouse.
Family as a Social Safety Net: In collectivist cultures, the family often serves as a primary social safety net.
This means that individuals are expected to rely on their family for support, whether emotional, financial, or otherwise. A husband might prioritize his family of origin because he views them as his primary support system, which can create friction in the marriage if his spouse feels neglected.
In contrast, individualist cultures, such as those prevalent in the United States, Canada, and much of Western Europe, emphasize personal autonomy and self-fulfillment. In these societies, the marital relationship is often viewed as the primary unit, and there is an expectation that spouses will prioritize each other above their families of origin.
Marriage as a Partnership: In individualist cultures, marriage is often seen as a partnership between equals, where both partners are expected to support each other in pursuing their personal goals and aspirations. If a husband from an individualist background prioritizes his family of origin, it can be seen as a violation of the marital contract, leading to feelings of betrayal and resentment from his spouse.
Balancing Dual Expectations: In multicultural or bicultural marriages, where partners come from different cultural backgrounds, the challenge of balancing family and marital obligations can be particularly pronounced. A husband from a collectivist culture may struggle to meet the expectations of his individualist spouse, leading to misunderstandings and conflicts.
Patriarchal Values and Gender Roles
In many cultures, patriarchal values continue to influence family dynamics and marital relationships.
Traditional gender roles often dictate that men are responsible for supporting and protecting their family of origin, while women are expected to prioritize the needs of their husband and children.
This can create a situation where a husband feels justified in putting his family's needs above his spouse's, leading to a power imbalance in the marriage.
Gendered Expectations of Caregiving: In patriarchal societies, men may be expected to take on the role of the primary caregiver for their parents, especially as they age.
This expectation can be particularly strong if the husband is the eldest son, as he may be seen as the natural heir to the role of family leader and caretaker. This can create a conflict of interest between fulfilling his familial duties and being emotionally available to his spouse.
Control and Authority: In some cultures, patriarchal values grant men authority over their wives, which can manifest in a husband's decision to prioritize his family of origin over his marriage.
If a wife challenges this behavior, it may be seen as a challenge to the husband's authority, leading to further conflict and tension.
Impact of Immigration and Acculturation
For couples in immigrant families, the dynamics of prioritizing family can become even more complex due to the pressures of acculturation and the desire to maintain cultural traditions in a new environment.
Immigrant husbands may feel a strong obligation to support their family of origin, especially if they were the first to migrate and are expected to send financial support back home.
Acculturation Stress: The process of acculturation—adapting to a new culture while maintaining one's original cultural identity—can create significant stress for immigrant couples.
A husband may feel pressured to uphold traditional cultural values, including loyalty to his family of origin, even as he navigates the expectations of his new environment. This can lead to a situation where he prioritizes his family's needs out of a sense of duty, despite the strain it places on his marriage.
Cultural Preservation: For many immigrant families, preserving cultural traditions and values is a priority.
A husband may prioritize his family of origin as a way to maintain a connection to his cultural roots, especially if he feels that his spouse or children are becoming too assimilated into the dominant culture. This can create a rift in the marriage if his spouse feels that their relationship is being sidelined in favor of cultural preservation.
Therapeutic Approaches to Cultural Issues
Family therapists must navigate these cultural complexities with sensitivity and awareness. An effective therapeutic approach will involve understanding the cultural context in which the couple operates and helping them find a balance that respects both cultural traditions and the needs of the marriage.
Cultural Competence: A culturally competent therapist will take the time to understand the cultural background of both partners, including their beliefs about family, marriage, and individual roles. This understanding allows the therapist to frame discussions in a way that honors the couple's cultural values while addressing the specific issues they face.
Facilitating Open Dialogue: Encouraging open and honest communication about cultural expectations can help both partners understand each other's perspectives. The therapist might guide the couple in discussing how cultural values shape their behavior and explore ways to integrate those values into their marriage without compromising their relationship.
Balancing Cultural and Marital Expectations: The therapist can work with the couple to find a balance between honoring cultural obligations and prioritizing the marital relationship. This might involve setting clear boundaries with the family of origin, creating new traditions that reflect the couple's shared values, and developing strategies to manage cultural pressures.
Empowerment and Autonomy: Helping the husband develop a sense of autonomy while maintaining a connection to his family can be a key therapeutic goal. The therapist might use techniques from Bowenian therapy to promote differentiation, enabling the husband to make decisions that honor both his family and his marriage.
Addressing Gender Roles: If traditional gender roles are contributing to the conflict, the therapist might explore how these roles are impacting the marriage and encourage the couple to redefine their roles in a way that supports mutual respect and partnership. This could involve challenging patriarchal assumptions and empowering the wife to assert her needs within the marriage.
Cultural factors are deeply intertwined with the dynamics of marital relationships, particularly when it comes to the issue of a husband prioritizing his family of origin over his spouse. Understanding the cultural context in which these dynamics occur is essential for effective therapy.
A good family therapist can help couples navigate the complexities of cultural expectations, establish healthy boundaries, and create a balanced relationship that honors both their marriage and their family ties.
Therapeutic Approaches
Establishing Clear Boundaries: A family therapist would work with the couple to establish clear and healthy boundaries between the marital relationship and the family of origin. This involves helping the husband understand the importance of prioritizing his marriage and developing strategies to maintain an appropriate balance between his family obligations and his commitment to his spouse.
Addressing Enmeshment: If enmeshment is a significant factor, the therapist may explore the husband's relationship with his family of origin, helping him to differentiate himself while still maintaining a supportive connection. This process, known as "differentiation of self," is crucial in allowing the husband to develop a more autonomous identity that supports both his marriage and his family relationships.
Cultural Sensitivity: The therapist would approach the issue with cultural sensitivity, recognizing and respecting the cultural values that may influence the husband's behavior. The goal is to find a balance that honors cultural traditions while also prioritizing the health and stability of the marriage.
Communication Skills: Improving communication between the couple is essential. The therapist would help the wife express her feelings and concerns constructively while encouraging the husband to listen and respond empathetically. Effective communication can help the couple navigate the challenges of balancing family obligations and marital needs.
Couples Counseling: Engaging in couples counseling can provide a safe space for both partners to express their concerns and work towards a solution. A science-based couples therapist might use techniques from Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) to help the couple reconnect emotionally and strengthen their bond, ensuring that their marriage quality remains a profound priority.
Family Therapy: In some cases, involving the husband's family of origin in therapy sessions might be beneficial. This approach can help address the underlying dynamics and improve relationships between all parties. The therapist would guide the family in setting appropriate boundaries and fostering a healthier relationship that supports the couple's marriage.
Final thoughts
When a husband prioritizes his family over his spouse, it can lead to significant marital conflict.
Understanding the underlying dynamics, such as enmeshment, cultural expectations, and emotional cutoffs, can provide insight into the issue.
A family therapist can help the couple establish clear boundaries, improve communication, and navigate the cultural and emotional complexities of the situation.
With the right support, it is often possible to find a balance that honors both the marriage and family relationships.
Be Well, Stay Kind, and Godspeed.
REFERENCES:
Berry, J. W. (1997). Immigration, Acculturation, and Adaptation. Applied Psychology: An International Review, 46(1), 5-34.
Bowen, M. (1978). Family Therapy in Clinical Practice. New York: Jason Aronson.
Johnson, S. M. (2004). The Practice of Emotionally Focused Couple Therapy: Creating Connection. New York: Routledge.
Kagitcibasi, C. (2007). Family, Self, and Human Development Across Cultures: Theory and Applications. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Minuchin, S. (1974). Families and Family Therapy. Harvard University Press.
Olson, D. H., & Gorall, D. M. (2006). FACES IV and the Circumplex Model. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 32(1), 7-28.
Triandis, H. C. (1995). Individualism and Collectivism. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
